Cockroach Control Manual
42
Insecticide Classes
The classes of insecticides listed here are
grouped based on their chemical structures and the
way they kill cockroaches.
Chlorinated Hydrocarbons—Banned: A few
chlorinated hydrocarbons are DDT, aldrin, endrin,
and chlordane. Throughout the 1970’s and 80’s,
the EPA banned most chlorinated hydrocarbons
from sale and use in the United States because
these insecticides persisted in the environment and
increased in the fatty tissues of animals. None of
these insecticides should be used in cockroach
control.
Organophosphates (OPs)—Old Standards,
no longer used: The OPs were discovered in
Germany during World War II research on nerve
gas poisons. Some of the more common OPs
used in cockroach control until recently were
chlorpyrifos (Dursban
®
), diazinon, and acephate
(Orthene
®
). Changes in environmental laws have
resulted in the elimination of most indoor uses of
these insecticides. We do not recommend the use
of these insecticides for cockroach control.
Carbamates—Early Alternatives, much
reduced use: In 1951, carbamate insecticides were
introduced into the world market. There are two
carbamates labeled for cockroach control in and
around the home: propoxur (Baygon
®
) and carbaryl
(Sevin
®
). Most indoor uses of these insecticides
have been eliminated. We do not recommend the
use of these insecticides for cockroach control.
Botanicals—Naturally Occurring: Botanicals
are natural insecticides, made from plant extracts.
When processed and concentrated, these botanical
insecticides are similar to synthetic insecticides.
Some people believe natural-occurring botanicals
are safer to use than synthetic insecticides. This is
not necessarily the case. Nicotine sulfate, a botanical
derived from tobacco plants, is more toxic to
mammals than many synthetic insecticides.
Oil extracts of the neem tree seeds, the herb
thyme, mint, citrus peels (limonene), cloves
(eugenol), and phenethyl propinate are sometimes
used for cockroach control. Studies have shown
these extracted oils have limited toxic activity
on cockroaches and are virtually nontoxic to
mammals. They are useful as contact sprays only
(kill on contact), with little or no residual activity.
These oil extract botanicals were developed in
response to public demand for more “natural” and
safer products.
Another, older, botanical insecticide used for
cockroach control is pyrethrum. Pyrethrum is a
mixture of several compounds, including pyrethrins
and cinerin. Pyrethrum has low mammalian
toxicity but very fast knock-down activity, causing
rapid paralysis in the target insects. However, the
paralysis may only be temporary unless a synergist
(such as piperonyl butoxide or MGK 264) is added.
The synergist may have no insecticidal property,
but enhances the activity of an insecticide.
To improve on the effectiveness of pyrethrum,
chemists have synthesized similar, more stable
compounds in the laboratory. These laboratory-
created insecticides are known as the synthetic
pyrethroids or simply pyrethroids.
Pyrethroids—New Age Insecticides:
There have been dozens of pyrethroids identified
and synthesized. A few include esfenvalerate,
permethrin, tetramethrin, deltamethrin,
cypermethrin and cyfluthrin. Notice nearly all
pyrethroid insecticides end with ‘thrin’. This is
because these newly synthesized chemicals were
modeled after pyrethrins. Chemists have made these
compounds more stable and more persistent than
natural pyrethrum. A synergist is usually added
to the pyrethroid formulation to further increase
its effectiveness. One characteristic of pyrethroids
is when a cockroach encounters the insecticide,
it becomes more excited and active. Because of
this, after an application of a pyrethroid you may
see cockroaches during the day when previously
you have only seen them at night. This change in
behavior means the insect is being affected by the
insecticide.
Like the botanical pyrethrum, pyrethroids have
fast knock-down activity especially against flying
insects and low mammalian toxicity. Pyrethroids
are very toxic against fish so precautions must be
taken to cover fish tanks and disconnect filters
when using , at the very least. Pyrethroids are the
active ingredients in most of the in-home aerosols
you can buy (Raid
®
, Black Flag
®
, etc) and in the RTU