June 14, 2023
VIA EMAIL
Lynne Fox, International President
Workers United, an SEIU Affiliate
22 South 22nd Street
Philadelphia, PA 19103
RE: Workers United’s Willfully and Recklessly False Statements and Blatant Fear Mongering
Among the LGBTQIA2+ Community
Dear Ms. Fox,
This responds to your May 31, 2023 letter which states it “has come to [Workers United’s] attention
Starbucks has implemented a change in health care benefits for employees at represented stores
concerning gender affirming care.”
At Starbucks, we have a rich history of advocacy and support for our LGBTQIA2+ partners and
customers. We've worked for more than four decades to create a welcoming environment for the
LGBTQIA2+ community through inclusive policies, industry leading same-sex and gender affirming
care benefits, advocacy efforts and support for community causes. Indeed, since 2013, Starbucks
health insurance plans have included coverage for gender-affirming surgery. In 2018,
Starbucks expanded health insurance plan coverage to include procedures that were previously
considered cosmetic including hair removal, facial feminization and hair transplants, among others.
This support has not changed, regardless of your false claims and attempts to divide the inclusive
communities that Starbucks supports. It is unfortunate that Workers United continues to knowingly
and recklessly spread inaccurate information seemingly to mislead partners into believing they lost
health benefits that could be critical to their mental and physical well-being. The Company’s decade-
long provision of same-sex and gender affirming care to Starbucks partners has not changed. All
partners enrolled in Starbucks health benefits have access to industry-leading gender-affirming care
benefits regardless of organizing activity or representation status.
Since instituting these benefits as part of this Company’s industry-leading, comprehensive health
care offerings, gender affirming care has remained part of either the Company’s core health
insurance plan or its additional wrap plan offered to partners. Whether specific same-sex and
gender affirming care, services, and procedures are covered as part of the Company’s core health
insurance plan or its additional wrap plan depends upon the state law applicable to the Company’s
plans and, more specifically, whether the care, services, and procedures are required to be part of
Starbucks core health insurance plan offerings. The structure of the Company’s same-sex and
gender affirming care benefits has shifted multiple times over this last decade, after 2018 with the
shift being dictated by changes to state law. This is true with respect to recent changes to state law,
which require that certain same-sex and gender affirming care, services, and procedures be covered
by the Company’s core plan. However, in that time, the Company has not “changed” its benefits
plans or procedures, or limited access to the care, services, and procedures available to all enrolled
and benefits eligible partners. As such, Starbucks has not made any change to the same-sex and
gender affirming care benefits provided to partners, or other terms and conditions of employment
offered to Store partners in any certified store that would trigger a decisional or effects bargaining
obligation. Indeed, any alleged change would be consistent with the maintenance of dynamic status
quo.
On a related and timely note, I am also writing to express my deep and urgent concern about the
blatant fear mongering campaign launched recently by Workers United, especially the knowingly and
recklessly false statements that Starbucks corporate had “banned” PRIDE related décor in all
stores. NOTHING could be further from the truth. It is disgraceful that Workers United would take a
month of celebration, reflection, self-esteem, self-worth, and yes PRIDE that means so much to
so many of our 235,000 partners across the country, and use it to fear monger and sow division and
hate.
The TRUE facts are these:
We unwaveringly support the LGBTQIA2+ community. There has been no change to any
corporate policy on this matter and we continue to empower retail leaders to celebrate with
their communities including for U.S. Pride month in June.
For Starbucks, U.S. Pride Month in June is just one of the moments we support and
celebrate our LGBTQIA2+ partners and the community.
Starbucks has a history that includes more than four decades of recognizing and celebrating
our diverse partners and customers including year-round support for the LGBTQIA2+
community.
Workers United can also find a timeline that outlines the company’s longstanding support for our
LGBTQIA2+ partners, here, that predates any involvement from your organization. A few highlights:
1988: Starbucks extends full health benefits to eligible full- and part-time partners,
including coverage for same-sex domestic partnerships.
2007: Starbucks issues Workplace Gender Transition Guidelines to support partners who are
transgender or considering transitioning to promote understanding of fair and equitable
treatment of transgender and gender-diverse partners.
2013: Starbucks supports transgender partners by adding coverage of gender reassignment
surgery to the company’s health benefits.
2015: Starbucks updates its technology systems to ensure that documentation in stores
reflect a partner’s “known as” name or nickname that is consistent with their gender identity
or expression.
2018: Starbucks broadens its health insurance options for transgender partners to not only
include gender reassignment surgery (which had been covered since 2013), but also a host
of procedures that were previously considered cosmetic, such as breast reduction or
augmentation surgery, facial feminization, hair transplants and more.
Starbucks partnered with the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) to
create a transgender medical policy that is inclusive of medical services that most companies have
historically considered cosmetic. Anyone who is eligible and enrolled in Starbucks health benefits
has access to these benefits.
It is willfully and recklessly false to claim that Starbucks is anything other than a fully supportive
ally of this community that makes up a significant part of our workforce. This is shameful behavior
and I’m calling on you to demand that WU representatives cease this false, harmful, and despicable
narrative. We can have many different points of view about unions, but we should ALL have the same
vision for how all people, including LGBTQIA2+ people, should be treated with respect, support
and allyship. Using this month of recognition and pride as a means to sow division in an attempt to
gin up union support is none of those things.
With respect to the requests for information included in your May 31, 2023 letter, Starbucks objects
to your attempt to request information without identifying the specific bargaining unit for which you
request this information. These requests yet another transparent attempt by you and Workers United
to circumvent the single-store certifications and to demand “national” bargaining. Starbucks again
rejects any attempt by Workers United to bargain on a national scale. Single-store bargaining is the
structure that Workers United sought, and this is the structure that the NLRB determined to be
“appropriate” for purposes of collective bargaining.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, Starbucks acknowledges receipt of your requests for information and
will respond in the near future.
Sincerely,
May Jensen
vice president, partner resources