© 2013 Fannie Mae. Trademarks of Fannie Mae. SVC-2013-20 Page 5
90 days or more before a scheduled foreclosure sale or if a foreclosure sale date is unknown, and
with respect to a mortgage loan secured by a principal residence.
The appeal process applies only to a denial of any mortgage loan modification trial period plan(s) if it relates to
the first complete BRP and meets all of the above requirements.
NOTE: A servicer’s appeal decision is final and not subject to further appeal. Foreclosure prevention
alternatives (workout options) that do not require a complete BRP do not have the right to an appeal.
Borrower Requirements Relating to an Appeal
Servicers must confirm that the borrower properly exercised an appeal in connection with a BRP that satisfies
the above requirements by ensuring that the borrower, within 14 days of the date of the servicer’s Evaluation
Notice, provides the servicer with a written request for an appeal that includes the borrower’s name, property
address, and mortgage loan number.
The servicer must inform the borrower that any supporting documentation and specific appeal reason may be
submitted at the time the servicer is notified of the appeal.
Servicer Requirements Relating to an Appeal
Servicers must complete the review of a borrower’s appeal using personnel different from those responsible for
the initial evaluation of and decision on the complete BRP. Servicers must provide written notice of the appeal
decision within 30 days of receipt of the borrower’s appeal.
If the borrower’s appeal is received within the 14-day appeal period,
• the servicer must evaluate the appeal and must accept any new information submitted by the borrower
within this timeframe as part of the independent appeal review (whether the information relates to the
appeal, i.e., modification denial, or a material change of circumstances unrelated to the appeal).
If any new information or documentation submitted by the borrower is received after the 14-day
appeal period in connection with a borrower’s timely appeal but before the appeal decision, or if the
borrower’s appeal is received after the 14-day appeal period,
• the servicer must provide written notice of the appeal decision within 30 days of receipt of the borrower’s
appeal. In these cases, the servicer has the discretion to
o
complete the review with any new information or documentation provided by the borrower as part of
the appeals process; or
o
treat the request along with any additional information as part of a new BRP and review the BRP in
accordance with existing requirements in Part VII, Section 205: Letters and Part VIII, Section 107:
Conduct of Foreclosure Proceedings of the Servicing Guide.
If the borrower elects to appeal, the borrower does not have to accept the initial offer for a workout option until
resolution of the appeal. If, after review of an appeal, the servicer determines that the borrower was eligible for
a loan modification trial period plan for which the borrower had been denied, the servicer must send the
borrower an offer for such loan modification trial period plan. In that case, the borrower may choose to accept
the initial offer, provided that the borrower continues to be eligible for such offer, or the new loan modification
trial period plan offer, and must be given 14 calendar days from the date of the servicer’s appeal decision
notice to indicate their intent to accept either offer. The borrower’s intent to accept an offer may be indicated by
verbal or written notification or by making the first trial period plan payment within 14 days, in accordance with
the Servicing Guide.
If the borrower waits to accept the initial offer until after receiving the appeal decision, the servicer must