Microsoft Word - MLCC 2016 easement presentation.docx

Easements & Rights of Way, Public and Private Roads

"#$%$&'$(!)*!+'',#&$*!-#$&$!.$/!0,&,!

12%%2345%$''%!62&(!7,&%$#82'9,&!7,&:$#$&3$!;<=!+>#9/!;=!; ? @A!

+&!9&'#,(53'9,&!',!$2%$B$&'%C!-&!+6 6 !3 2 % $ %=!' 4 $ ! ,5'3,B$%!2#$!($>$&($&'!,&!9&(989(52/!($'29/%!2&(!35##$&'!/2DC!!

Neither'this'document'nor'discussions'at'the'MLCC'are'to'be'construed'as'legal'advice.!E5$%'9,&%!#$F2#(9&F!

9&(989(5 2/ !$2%$B $&'!#9F4'%!2&(!>5)/93!2&(!>#982'$!D2*%!32&!,&/*!)$!2&%D$#$(!)*!2!'9'/$!$G2B9&2'9,&=!9&3/5( 9& F!

%5##,5&(9&F!2&(!&$2#)*!>#,>$#'9$%=!>5)/93!2&(!49%',#93!#$3,#(%=!2&(!2>>/*9&F!'4$!#$/$82&'!/2D=!#$H59#9&F!'4$!

%$#893$%!,:!2&!2'',#&$*!8$#%$(!9&!'9'/$%!2&(!$2%$B$&'%C!!

Bolded!D,#(%!9&(932'$!/$F2/!'$#B%!,#!I'$#B%!,:!2#'JC!K&($#/9&$(!D,#(%!2#$!4$/>:5/!D2*%!',!#$B$B)$#!'4$!/$F2/!

'$#B%!,#!L$*!>,9&'%C!!

I. Easements**

• +&!easement!9%!2!#9F4'!',!5%$!%,B$,&$!$/%$M%!>#,>$#'*!9&!'4 $ !D 2 * %!($%3#9)$(!9&!'4$!$2%$B$&'C!!!

N49%!32&!9&3/5($!2!%42#$(!(#98$D2*=!2!>#982'$!#,2(=!2!#9F4'!',!3,&8$*!D2'$#!'4#,5F4!>9>$%!#5&&9&F!5&($#!

%,B$,&$!$/%$M%!>#,>$#'*=!2!#9F4'!'2L$!%,B$'49&F!%534!2%!F#28$/!,#!D2'$#!:#,B!%,B$,&$!$/%$M%!>#,>$#'*=!2!

#9F4'!',!:/,,(!%, B $ ,& $ !$/% $M%!> #, > $# '* !,#!', !L $$ > !'4$ !8 $F $' 2'9, & !35 '!', !2//, D !:/* 9& F!, 8$ #!'4 $ !># ,> $ #'* C!

• N4$!>#,>$#'*!%5)O$3'!',!'4$!$2%$B$&'=!,#!'42 ' !42%!'4$!$2%$B$&'!,8$#!9'=!9%!32//$(!'4$!burdened',#!servient'

>#,>$#'*C!N4$!fee!9%!2&, '4 $ #!'$ #B!5%$(!', !( $& , '$ !'4 $ !/2& (!'42'!9%!)5#($&$(!) *!'4$!$2 %$B $ &'=!2%!9&!I'4$ !

2)5''$#%!,D&!'4$!:$$!5&($#!'4$!#,2(JC!!N4$!%$#89$&'!,D&$#!42%!'4$!#9F4'!',!5%$!'4$!/2&(!9&!2&*!D2* !'42'!(, $%!

&,'!9&'$#:$#$!D9'4!'4$!$2%$B$&'!,#!B2L$!9'%!5%$!B,#$!3,%'/*!:,#!'4$!$2%$B$&'!4,/($#C'

• +!>#,>$#'*!'42'!42%!2''234$(!',!9'!'4$!#9F4'!',!5%$!%,B $,&$!$/%$M%!>#,>$#'*!9%!32//$(!' 4$ !benefited',#'

dominant'>#,>$#'*C!!

• P4$&!2&!$2%$B$&'!9%!I2''234$(!',J!2!>#,>$#'*=!9'!9%!32//$(!2&!appurtenant!$2%$B$& 'C!!

N4$!)$&$:9'$(!>2#3$/!(,$%!&,'!428$!',!(9#$3'/*!2)5'!$8$#*!)5#($&$(!>#,>$#'*Q!:,#!9&%'2&3$=!2!>#982'$!#,2(!

B2*!)5#($&!B5/'9>/$!>2#3$/%!2/,&F!9'%!#,5'$C!R234!>2#3$/!'42'!42%!'4$!#9F4'!',!5%$!'4$!#,2(!9%!2!)$&$:9'$(!

>2#3$/Q!$234!>2#3$/!'42'!42%!'4$!#,2(!#5&&9&F!23#,%%!9'!D,5/(!)$!2!)5#($&$(!>2#3$/C!!

• P4$&!2&!$2%$B$&'!9%!&,'!2''234$(!',!2!>2#'935/2#!>#,>$#'*=!9'!9%!32//$(!2&!easemen t'in'gross=!,#!personal!

',!'4$!35##$&'!)$& $:9'$(!4 ,/($# C!!!

N4$!/2D!(9%:28,#%!$2%$B$&'%!9&!F#,%%!2&(!D9//!F$&$#2//*!:9&(!'42'!'4$*!$G>9#$!D4$&!'4$!>$#%,&!D 4, !4,/(% !

'4$!$2%$B$& '! &,!/,&F$#!)$&$:9'%!:#,B!9'C!S,#!9&%'2&3$=!%,B$,&$!B2*!428$!'4$!#9F4'!',!F,!23#,%%!2!>#,>$#'*!

',!F$'!',!'4$!D2'$#!',!:9%4C!P 4 $&!'42 '!>$# %,& !(9$%=!,#!B ,8$ %!2D 2* !%,!&, !/,&F $#!42%!2&*!>#23'932/!5%$!:,#!'4$!

#9F4'=!3,5#'%!D9//!:9&(!'42'!'4$!#9F4'!42%!$G>9#$(C!!Public'easements=!,#!'4,%$!D 9' 4 !2 'public'benefit!%534!2%!

>5)/93!D2*%=!#29/#,2(%=!>5)/93!T2&(!>#982'$U!5'9/9'*!2&(!,'4$#!%$#893$!$2%$B$&'%!(,!&,'!$G>9#$C!N4$*!B5%'!)$!

$G'9&F59%4$(!9&!'4 $ !B 2 & &$ #!> # ,8 9( $ (!) * !/2 D C!

• +!negative'easement=!,#!restriction=!F98$%!'4$!)$& $ :9' $ ( !4 , / ( $ # !'4$!/$F2/!#9F4'!',!>#$8$& '!2&, '4$#!

>#,>$#'*!:#,B!)$9&F!5%$(!9&!2! D2*!9'!3,5/(!,'4$#D9%$!)$!5%$(C!!

V$%'#93'9,&%!2#$!(9%:28,#$(!9&!'4$!/2D =!)$ 32 5 % $!'4$ !/2D !:28, #% !'4 $!:5 //!5% $!, :!/2& ( C!!-&!2&!$::,#'!',!$G'9&F59%4!

#$%'#93'9,&%=!%'2'5',#*!>#,89%9,&%!9&!12%%2345%$''%!W$&$#2/!62D%!342>'$#!@XY!%$3'9,&%!;Z=!;A[ZZ!D$#$!

$&23'$(!',!$G'9&F59%4!#$%'#93'9,&%!'42'!2#$!&,!/,&F$#!,:!)$&$:9'=!2&(!>#,89($%!2!>#,3$%%!:,#!'4$!3,&'9&52'9,&!

,:!'4,%$!'42'!2#$!%'9//!,:!)$&$:9'C!!

• IPerpetual'restrictionsJ!D4934!(,!&,'!$G>9#$!2#$!&,!/,&F$#!2//,D$(!$G3$>'!:,#!F,8$#&B$&'2/!#$%'#93'9,&%!

,#!'4,%$!D9'4!2!>5)/93!)$&$:9'!,#!'4,%$!3,B>/*9&F!D9'4!3C!@XY!%$3C!;Z=!;A[ZZC!!\,B$!#$%'#93'9,&%!B5%'!)$!

$G'$&($(!)*!:9/9&F!2!&,'93$!,:!$G'$&%9,&!9&!'4$!V$F9%'#*!,:!.$$(%!9&!233,#( 2 & 3$ !D 9' 4!' 4$ !#$ H 5 9#$ B $ & '% !,:!' 4$ !

/2D=!>#,89($(!'42'!'4$!#$%'#93'9,&!9%!%'9//!,:!)$&$:9'C!

• Right'of'way!9%!2!'*>$!,:!$2% $ B $ & '!'4 2 '!2 //, D % !, &/ *!2 !/9B 9' $( !#9F 4 '!',!>2%%!2&(!#$>2%%!T)5'!&,'!>2#LU'

• Benefited'property'owner!42%!'4$!#9F4'!',!9B>#,8$!'4$!$2%$B$&'!2&(!B2L$!9'!5%2)/$!:,#!9'%!9&'$&($(!

>5#>,%$T%UC!N49%!9&3/5($%!>289&F=!>5''9&F!9&!%9($D2/L%=!5'9/9'9$%=!/9F4'9&F=!#$B,89&F!,)%'#53'9,&%=!'#$$%!,#!

%',&$!D2//%=!$8$&!9:!>/23$(!'4$#$!)*!'4$!)5#($&$(!>#,>$#'*!,D&$#C!!K%$!,:!2&!$2%$B$&'!B2*!342&F$!2%!'4$!

&$$(%!,:!'4$!%$#89$&'!2&(!(,B9&2&'!,D&$#!342&F$C!!Western'Mass.'Electric'Co.'v.'Sambo’s'of'Mass.,'IncC=!X!

12%%C!+>>C!7'C!X@]=!X;;!T@^YYUC!

• Burdened'property'owner!42%!'4$!#9F4'!',!5%$!'4$!)5#($&$(!>#,>$#'* !9&!2&* !D 2*!D 4 934!(, $%!&, '!

9&'$#:$#$!D9'4!'4$!) $ &$ :9'$ ( !> #, > $ #'* !, D & $ #M%!# 9F4 '% !, #!'4 2 '!( ,$ % !&, '!B2'$#92//* !9& 3#$ 2 %$ !'4 $ !3, %' %!', !'4 $ !

)$&$:9'$(!,D&$#!',!9B>#,8$!,#!B2L$!5%$!,:!'4$!$2%$B$&'C'

II. Private*Easements*and*Ways**

• "#982'$!D2*%!B2*!)$!>#982'$=!)5'!,>$&!',!'4$!>5)/93C!!N49%!(,$ % !& , ' !B2L$!' 4 $ B!>5)/93!D2*%!:,#!D4934!'4$ !

B5&939>2/9'*!42%!'4$!)5#($&!,:!/92)9/9'*!2&(!B29&'$&2&3$C!K%$!,:!D,#(%!9 & !'4$!F#2& '!,:!2&!$2% $ B$&'!% 5 3 4 !2 % !

I:,#!'4$!>5#>,%$%!:,#!D4934!>5)/93!D2*%!9&!'4$!',D&!2#$!&,D!,#!B2*!4$#$2:'$#!)$!5%$(J!(,$%!&,'!B2L$!'4$!

$2%$B$&'!>5)/93C!McLaughlin'v.'Board'of'Selectmen'of'Amherst=!Y;;!1 2 % % C!Z ] ^ =!ZAY[ZA]!T@^^AUC!!

• +!B5&939>2/9'*!B2*!>/,D!2&(!B2L$!B9&,#!#$>29#%!',!>#982'$!D2*%!,&/*!9:!'4$*!2#$!I,>$&!',!'4$!>5)/93J!2&(!9:!

'4$!B5&939>2 /9'*!42%!2 (,> '$( !1CW C6C!3C!!Y?!%$3C!A7=!A.!2& (!A_ C!+//,D 9& F!'4$!> 5) /93!',!5%$!2!> #982'$ !D2 *!(, $%!

&,'!B2L$!9'!>5)/93!`!'42'!D ,5/( !#$H5 9#$!2!/2*, 5'!23 3,# (9&F !',!%'2'5 '$!2&( !2&!2 33$> '2& 3$!) *!'4$!B 5 &939> 2/9'*C!!

• V$%>,&%9)9/9'*!:,#!B29&'$&2&3$!2&(!9B>#,8$B$&'%!,&!>#982'$!D2*%!)$/,&F%!',!'4,%$!4289&F!'4$!)$&$:9'!,:!

'4$!D2*C!!a&$!,D&$#!32&!9B> #,8 $!'4$!$& '9#$'*!, :!'4$!$2%$ B $& '=!2&(!(, $%!&, '!&$$ (!'4$!> $#B 9%%9,& !,:!'4$!

)5#($&$(!>#,>$#'*!,D&$#%!',!B2L$!'4$!$2%$B$&'!5%2)/$!:,#!'4$!>5#>,%$!9'!D2%!F#2&'$(C!N4$#$!9%!2!

%'2'5',#*!>#,3$%%!:,#!#$H59#9&F!,'4$#!)$&$:9'$(!>#,>$#'*!,D &$#%!',!3,&'#9)5'$C

III. Public*Easements**

+!D2*!)$3,B$%!>5)/93!)*!:,//,D9&F!'4$!/$F2/!#$H59#$B$&'%!,:!2!/2*,5'!)*!2!>5)/93!25'4,#9'*=!,#!)* !2 !> # $ % 3# 9>'98$!

$2%$B$&'=!,#!>#9,#!',!'4$!\'C!,:!@XYA=!)*!($(932'9,&!2&(!233$>'2&3$C!.9%35%% 9,&!,:!'4$ !($'29/%!,:!$234!,:!'4$%$!9%!

)$*,&(!'4$!%3,>$!,:!'49%!(9%35%%9,&C!-'!9%!9B>,#'2&'!',!5& ($ #%'2& (!'4 2'!>5 ) /93!5%$!2 /,&$ =!,#!/2)$ /%!,&!> /2& %!,#!D ,# (%!

9&!($$(% !#$ :$# #9& F!' ,!2 !D 2 * !2% !> 5 ) /93=!( , $% !& ,' !B 2 L $!' 4$ !D2*!>5) /93 C!!

• Impro ve m e n ts'9&!>5)/93!D2*%!2#$!'4$!#$%>,&%9)9/9'*!,:!'4$!B5&939>2/9'*!,#!F,8$#&B$&'!,D&$#C!!Sturdy'v.'

Planning'Bd'of'Hingham=!Z;!12%%C!+ >>C!7'C!b ; =!b A !T @ ^ ^;UC!!"#98 2 '$ !9 & ( 98 9 ( 5 2 / %!F $ &$#2//*!B2*!&,'!B2L $ !B2O,#!

#$>29#%!,&!2!>5)/93!#,2(!D9'4,5'!25'4,#9'*=!)5'!B 2 * !>$'9'9,& !' , !4 2 8 $ !> 2 >$#!,#!9& 2 ( $ H52'$!> 5)/93!D 2 * % !

3,&%'#53'$(!,#!5>F#2($(=!2&(!'4$!B5&939>2/9'*!B2*!3,&'#23'!D9'4!2)5''$#%!',!(,!%,C!7:C!Perry'v.'Planning'

Board'of'Nantucket,!@]!12%%C!+>>C!7'C!@YY=!@]b[@]^!T@^XZUC!!T%$$!1CWC6C!3C!X;!%$3C!XUC'

• Ic1d$B)$#%!,:!'4$!>5)/93=!cd!2%!/2&(,D& $#%!2)5''9&F!2!>5 )/93!D2* e4 28$!2!#9F4'!',!'#28$#%$!'4$!unimproved'

portion!e!:,#!%534!>5#>,%$%!2%!2#$!I#$2%,&2)/*!&$3$%%2#*!2&(!3,&8$&9$&'J!:,#!233$%%!',!'4$9#!>#,>$#'*C!\$$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;

!Anderson'v.'Healy=!ZA!12%%C!+>>C!7'C!@Z@=!@Z]!T@^^YU!T+)5''$#!:,5&(!',!428$!9//$F2//*!)59/'!2!(#98$D2*!

2&(!9B>#,8$(!2&!5&9B>#,8$(!>,#'9,&!,:!2!35/!($!%23!,&!2!>5)/93!D2*!)5'!(9(!428$!'4$!/$F2/!#9F4'!',!5%$!

'4$!5&9B>#,8$(!>5)/93!D2*CU!K%$!,:!'4$!>5)/93!$2%$B$&'!',!F$'!',!*,5#!/2&(!I(,$%!&,'!3,&%'9'5'$!

'#$%>2%%ec2&(!*,5d!32&&,'!)$!>#$8$&'$(!:#,B!$&'$#9&F!:#,B!c*,5#d!/2&(!5>,&!2!D2*!D4934!'4$!>5)/93!42%!

Western'Mass.'Elec.'Co.'v.'Sambo’s,'IncC=!X!12%%C!+>>C!7' C!X @ ] =!X ;Y!T@^b ^UCJ

;

!62'$#!32%$%!2>>/*!2!#5/$!'42'!

>#,49)9'%!2)5''$#%!:#,B!9B>#,89&F!2!>,#'9,&!,:!2!/2*,5'!,&/*!D4$#$!'4$!B5&939>2/9'*!,D&%!'4$!:$$C

!!N4$!

#5/9&F!9&!Anderson'v.'Healy=!ZA!12% % C!+ >>C!7'C!@ Z @ =!@ Z ]!T@^^ YU!'42'!I9'!D2%!9B>#,>$#!:,#!'4$!($:$&(2&'%!',!

3,&%'#53'!2!(#98$D2*=!2&(!'42'!'4$!>28$(!>,#'9,&!,:!'4$!(#98$D2*!%4, 5/( !)$!#$B , 8$( J!9%!'#,5) /9& FC!6 2*,5'%!

2#$!#2#$/*!9B>#,8$(!',!'4$9#!:5//$%'!$G'$&'=!2&(!B2&*!$G'$&(!D$//!9&',!2)5''9&F!>#,>$#'9$%C!.#98$D2*%!'42'!

>#,89($!233$%%!',!2!>5)/93!D2*!2#$!2/B,%'!2/D2*%!)59/'!23#,%%!'4$!5&)59/'!>,#'9,&!,:!/2*,5'%C'

• Eminent'domain=!,#!condem nation=!TI ' 2 L 9&FJU!9%!2!' 2 L 9&F!)*!'4$!F,8$#&B$&'!,:!'4$!>#,>$#'*!#9F4'%!

($%3#9)$(!9&!'4$!'2L9&F!(,35B$&'=!233,B>/9%4$( !2 3 3,#(9&F!' , !2> >/932)/$!/2D% C!+!'2 L9& F !#$ H59# $% !2& !2 33 5 #2 '$ !

($%3#9>'9,&C!N4$!'2L9&F!(,35B$&'!B5%'!)$!$G2B9&$(!',!($'$#B9&$!D42'!D2%!'2L$&!2&(!D42'=!9:!2&*'49&F=!

#$B29&%C!+!'2L9&F!,:!/2&(!'42'!9%!%5)O$3'!',!2&!$2%$B$&'!$G'9&F59%4$%!'4$!$2%$B$&'!9:!'4$!'2L9&F!9%!,:!'4$!:$$!

,#!2//!9&'$#$%'%=!D9'4!&,!$G3$>'9,&!:,#!'4$!$2%$B$&'C

!N4$!'2L9&F!25'4,#9'*!B5%'!>2*!IO5%'!3,B>$&%2'9,&J!:,#!

#9F4'%!'2L$&C!-:!2!>#,>$#'*!9%!)5#($&$(!)*!2&!$2%$B$&'=!'4$!$2%$B$ &'!4,/( $ #!2 ' !'4$!'9B$ !,:!'4$!'2L9&F!9%!

$&'9'/$(!',!(2B2F$%C!P4$&!$G2B9&9&F!'9'/$!:,#!2!>#,>$#'*!'42' !42 %!'4 $!) $& $ :9'!,:!2 &!$ 2% $B$&'=!2/D2 *% !34 $3 L !

',!$&%5#$!'42'!'4$!$2 %$B $ &'!42 %!&,'!) $$& !$G'9&F 59%4 $(!) *!$B 9&$ &'!(, B 29& !,#!,'4$ #D 9%$C!'

• Abandonment!,:!2!>5)/93!D2*C!!\$$!WC6C!3C!X;=!%$3'9,&%!@;=!;@=!f!Z;+!2&(!Mahan'v.'Rockport=!;Xb!12% %C!ZY=!

Zb!T@^ZYUQ!Coombs'v.'Selectmen'of'Deerfield=!;A!12 % %C!+>>C!7' C!Z b^!T@^X XUC!'

• Discontinuance!,:!2!>5)/93!D2*!9%!D4$&!'4$!F , 8$ #& B$&'!F98$ %!5 > !'4 $ !#9F 4 '%!9'!23H59#$(!)*!$B 9&$&'!

(,B29&C!-:!'4$!'2L9&F!D2%!,:!2&!$2%$B$&'=!'4$!:$$!#$8$#'%!',!'4$!,#9F9&2/!,D&$#%=!,#!'4$9#!%533$%%,#%=!

5&)5#($&$(!)*!'4$!>5)/93!$2%$B$&'!:,#!'#28$/!2&(!F$&$#2//*!'4$*!#$F29&!'4$!:5//!,D&$#%49>!'42'!'4$*!42(!

>#9,#!',!'4$!'2L9&FC!Nylander'v.'Potter=!Y;Z!12 % % C!@ ] X =!;YA!T@^ ^AUC!!!-:!'4$!'2L9& F!D 2 %!,:!'4$!$& '9#$'* !,:!'4$ !

>#,>$#'*=!,#!I'4$!:$$J=!9'!3#$2'$%!2&!$&'9#$/*!&$D !'9'/$=!2&( !ID4$ &!'4$!>5) /93!5%$!9%!(9%3,&'9&5$(= !'4$!:$$!

#$B29&%!9&!'4$!'2L$#=!(9%342#F$(!:#,B !'4$!$2%$ B $&'C!Mount'Hope'Cemetery''v. Boston=!!@]X!12% %C!]?^=!]@ ; =!

2&(!25'4,#9'9$%!39'$(CJ!!Commonwealth'v.'Boston'Terminal'CoC=!@X]!12%%C!;X@=!;XA=!T12%%C!@^?YUC!-:!'4$!

'2L9&F!$G3$>'$ (!,5 '!$2%$ B $& '!,#!,'4$ #!#9F4'%=!'4,% $!#9F4'%!D , 5/(!3, &'9&5 $=!2%!)$ :,#$C!!-:!2//!#9F4'%!D$ #$!

'2L$&=!2&!2)5 ''$#!(, $%!&, '!,)'2 9&!2& !I2)5 ''$#%!$2 %$B $ &'J!,# !I>5) /93!233 $%%!>#98 2'$!D 2* J!5> ,& !

(9%3,&'9&52&3$!,:!'4$!#,2(C!Nylander.'-:!'4$!'D,!> #, > $# '9$% !(, !& ,'!4 2 8$ !2!3 ,BB,&!'9' /$=!'4 $# $!3 2& !) $!& , !

$2%$B$&'!)*!&$3$%%9'*=!$%',>>$/!,#!9B>/932'9,&C!!-&!%4,#'=!9:!*,5!,D&!>#,>$#'*!2/,&F!'4$!:,#B$#!>5)/93!D2*!

2&(!(9(!&,'!3/29B!(2B2F$%!:,#!'4$!$G'9&F59%4B$&'!,:!'4$!>5)/93!D2*=!*,5!D9//!&,'!F$'!(2B2F$%!&,#=!2)%$& '!

3$#'29&!39#35B%'2&3$%=!2&!$2%$B$&'!',!F$'!',!2&(!:#,B!*,5#!>#,>$#'*!892!'4$!:,#B$#!>5)/93!D2*C!N4$#$!

D,5/(!)$!&,!$2%$B$&'!)*!>#$%3#9>'9,&!:,#!5%$!(5#9&F!'4$!'9B$!'4$!D2*!D2%!2!>5)/93!D2*=!2%!>5)/93!5%$!9%!

>$#B9%%98$!2&(!(,$%!&,'!428$!'4$ !342#23'$#9%'93!,:!2(8$#%$!',!'4$!,D & $#M%!9&'$#$%'!#$H59#$(!:,#!2!

>#$%3#9>'98$!$2%$B$&'C!!

IV. “Other”*Easements*&*Ways*

• +&!easement'by'implication!B2*!)$!$%'2)/9%4$(!D4$&!2!>2#3$/!9%!3,&8$*$(!2&(!'4$#$!D2%!>#9,#!T5%52//* !

,>$&!2&(!,)89,5%U!5%$!,:!2&!233$%%!2&(!2&!9&'$&'9,&!)*!'4$!F#2&',#!',!9&3/5($!'42'!233$%%=!$8$&!9:!'4$!>2#3 $/!

42%!,'4$#!/$F2/!233$%%C!Dale'v.'Bedal=!Z?]!12%%C!@ ?;=!@?Z Q!Jo yce 'v.'D eva n ey=!Z ; ;!12%% C!] Y Y=!Y]^Q!Mt.'Holyoke'

Realty'Corp.'v.'Holyoke'Realty'CorpC!;XY!12 % % C!@ ? ? =!@?AC!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;

!Anderson'v.'Healy=!ZA!12%%C!+>>C!7'C!@Z@=!@Z]!T@^^YU!T+)5''$#!:,5&(!',!428$!9//$F2//*!)59/'!2!(#98$D2*!

2&(!9B>#,8$(!2&!5&9B>#,8$(!>,#'9,&!,:!2!35/!($!%23!,&!2!>5)/93!D2*!)5'!(9(!428$!'4$!/$F2/!#9F4'!',!5%$!

'4$!5&9B>#,8$(!>5)/93!D2*CU!K%$!,:!'4$!>5)/93!$2%$B$&'!',!F$'!',!*,5#!/2&(!I(,$%!&,'!3,&%'9'5'$!

'#$%>2%%ec2&(!*,5d!32&&,'!)$!>#$8$&'$(!:#,B!$&'$#9&F!:#,B!c*,5#d!/2&(!5>,&!2!D2*!D4934!'4$!>5)/93!42%!

2!#9F4'!',!5%$e+33$%%!',!2!>5)/93!D2*!9%!,&$!,:!'4$!9&39($&'%!,:!,D&$#%49>!,:!/2&(!),5&(9&F!'4$#$,&!2&(!

'49%!#9F4'!9%!2>>5#'$&2&'!',!'4$!/2&(!2&(!$G9%'%!D4$&!'4$!:$$!,:!'4$!D2*!9%!9&!'4$!B5&939>2/9'*!2%!D$//!2%!

D4$&!9'!9%!9&!>#982'$!,D&$#%49>CJ!Anzalone'v.'Metropolitan'District'Commission=!;]b!12%%C!Z;=!ZA!T@^;AUC!

!New'England'Continental'Media,'Inc.'v.'Town'of'Milton=!Z;!12%%C!+>>C!7'!;bY!T@^^;UC!!

• +&!easement'by'necessit*!9%!D4$&!2!>2#3$/!42%!&,!233$%%!TI)23L/2&(JU!2&( !2!>2#'*!',!'4$!($ $(!42% !!

2)5''9&F!/2&(!2'!'4$!'9B$!,:!'4$!F#2&'!'42'!32&!>#,89($!233$%%C!N4$!/2D!:28,#%!'4$!5%$!,:!/2&(=!2&(!%,!'4$!/2D!

D9//!F$&$#2//*!:9&(!9:!'4$#$!9%!&,!,'4$#!D2*!',!/$F2//*!233$%%!'4$!)23L/2&(=!'42'!233$ % % !, 8 $ # !' 4 $ !> 2 # '* M% !

2)5''9&F!/2&(!9%!2!&$3$%%9'*!:,#!'4$!5%$!,:!'4$!)23L/2&(C!!

• +!prescriptive'easement!9%!23H59#$ ( !) *!2 ( 8$ #% $!5 % $!3 , &' 9& 5 ,5 % /* !:,# !'4 $!> # $% 3# 9> '98 $!> $ #9, ( !T9& !1 + =!; ? !

*$2#%UC!K&/9L$!2(8$#%$!>,%%$%%9,&=!,&!D4934!>#$%3#9>'9,&!9%!)2%$(=!9'!&$$(!&,'!)$!$G3/5%98$C!\,!*,5!3,5/(!5%$!

'4$!$2%$B$& '!:,#!;? !*$2#% !2&( !,'4$# %=!9&3/5(9& F!'4$!, D &$# !,:!'4$!/2&( !,#!'4$!, D &$# !,:!/2&( !)$& $:9'$(!)* !'4$!

$2%$B$&'=!2&(!%'9//!23H59#$!'4$!#9F4'!',!3,&'9&5$!',!5%$!'4$!$2%$B$&'!9&!'4$!B2&&$#!'42'!*,5!5%$(!9'!:,#!'4$!

;?!*$2#!>$#9,(C!!

• Profit'a'prendre=!,:'$&!32//$ ( !I B9&$#2 /!# 9F 4 ' %J !, # !I F # 2 8 $ /!# 9F 4 ' %J !9% !' 4 $ !# 9F 4 ' !',!'2L$!% , B$'49& F =!5 % 52//*!

B9&$#2/%=!:#,B!'4$!/2&(C!!

• Doctrine'of'Emblements=!,#!'4$!# 9F 4 ' !',!42#8$ % '!3 # , >%!>/2&'$(!D4$&!'4$*!B2'5#$C!

• Plans'showing'easementsC!I+!>/2&!c9:d!#$:$##$(!',!9&!2!($$(!)$3,B$%!2!>2#'!,:!'4$!3,&'#23'!%,!:2#!2%!B2 *!

)$!&$3$%%2#*!e!!',!($'$#B9&$!'4$!#9F4'%!9&'$&($(!',!)$!3,&8$*$(C!I!Murphy'v.'Mart'Realty'of'Brockton,'Inc.,!

ZYX!12%%C!Ab]!T@^A]UC!!!

• Paper'Streets!2#$!D2*%!I%4,D&!,&!2!#$3,#($( !>/2&!)5'!&$8$ #!)59/'!,&!'4$!F#,5&( CJ!!Shapiro'v.'Burton=!;Z!

12%%C+>>C7'C!Z;b=!Z;X!T@^XbUC!+//!'4,%$!D9'4!#9F4'%!9&!2!>2>$#!%'#$$'!428$!'4$!#9F4'!',!9B>#,8$!9'C!

R/9B9&2'9,&!,:!2!>2>$#!%'#$$'!%4,5/(!)$!233,B>/9%4$(!)*!#$3,#(2)/$!#$/$2%$%!:#,B!2//!'4,%$!4289&F!#9F4'%!9&!

'4$!D2*=!Anderson'v.'Devries=!Z;A!1 2 % % C!@ ; b =!@Z;!T@^ ]?U=!,#!2!3,5#'!23'9,&!$G'9&F59%49&F!'4$!#9F4'%C!S9/9&F!

>/2&!5&($#!3C!Y@!%$3C!X@P!(,$%!&,'!$/9B9&2'$!#9F4'%!9&!'4$!>2>$#!%'#$$'=!2&(!2!>$'9'9,& $#!9%!&,'!$& '9'/$(!',!

'4$!>/2&&9&F!) ,2# (M%!$&( ,#%$ B $& '!9:!9'!D9//!2::$3'!'4$!#9F4'%!,:!,'4 $#%C!I+::$3'J !42%!) $$& !9&'$#># $'$( !2%!

9B>29#9& F !#9F 4' %!, #!B2#L$'2 ) 9/9'* !,:!, '4 $ #!> $ , > /$M% !> #, > $# '* C!!Patelle'v.'Planning'Board'of'Woburn=!;?!

12%%C+>>C!7'C!;b^!T@^X]UC!!!!

• IP4$#$!/2&(!9%!3,&8$*$( !D9'4!#$:$#$&3$ !',!2!>/2&=!2&!$2%$B$ &'!,'4$#!'42&!2& !$2%$B $&'!,:!&$3$%%9'*!9%!

3#$2'$(!,&/*!9:!3/$2#/*!%,!9&'$&($(!)*!'4$!>2#'9$%!',!'4$!($$(C!Regan!8C!Boston'Gas'Light'Co.!@Zb!12%%C!Zb=!YZC!

Prentiss!8C!Gloucester,!;ZA!12%%C!ZA=!];C!Bacon!8C!Onset'Bay'Grove'Assn.!;Y@!12%%C!Y@b=!Y;ZC!!!V+<-66g!8C!

+..-\a_!Z]?!12%%C!AA?=!662!T12%%C!@^AAUC!

• R234!%534!h9&'$&($(!$2%$B$&'h!($>$&(%!,&!'4$!($$(!2&(!'4$!39#35B%'2&3$%!9&!D4934!9'!D2%!B2($C!Bacon!8C!

Onset'Bay!Grove'Assn.!;Y@!12%%C!Y@b=!Y;ZC!Wellwood!8C!Havrah'Mishna'Anshi'Sphard'Cemetery'Corp.!;]Y!

12%%C!Z]?=!Z]Y[Z]]C!Mt.'Holyoke'Realty'Corp.!8C!Holyoke'Realty'Corp.!;XY!12%%C!@??=!@?YC!\$$!Goldstein!8C!

Beal,!Z@b!12%%C!b]?=!b]]C!

• Common'SchemeC!!I<,D$8$#=!h c 'd 4 $ !$ G 9% ' $ & 3 $ !, :!C!C!C!2 !)59/(9& F !% 34$B$!C!C!C!c B2*d!%4 ,D!2&!9 & '$ &'9,&!'4 2 ' !'4$!

#$%'#93'9,&%!9B>,%$(!5>,&!'4$ !%$8$#2/!/,'%!%42//!)$!2>>5 #'$&2& '!',!$8$#*!,'4$#!/,'!9&!'4$!'#23'!9&3/5($(!9&!

'4$!%34$B$Ch!Snow!8C!Van'Dam,!;^@!12%%C!Ybb=!YX@=!2&(!32 % $ %!3 9' $ ( C!N4$!34# , & ,/,F*!, :!' 4 $ !3 , & 8 $ * 2 & 3 $ % !, :!

'4$!%$8$#2/!/,'%!,5'!,:!'4$!%5)(989%9,&!9&!'4$!>#$%$&'!32%$!D2%!&,!,)%'23/$!',!'4$!:9&(9&F!,:!'4$!O5(F$!:,#!

'4$#$!D2%!$89($ &3$ !%5::939$&'!',!%5 >> ,#'!2 !%34$B$!,&!'4$!>2#'!,:!'4$!3, B B ,& !F#2 &', #C!+!:9&(9&F !,:!2!%34$ B $!

D2%!2B>/*!D2##2&'$(!9&!'49%!32%$!D4$#$!/2&F52F$!,335##$(!9&!$234!,:!'4$!,#9F9&2/!($$(%!:#,B!N$DL%)5#*!

F989&F!'4$!#$%>$3'98$!F#2&'$$%!2&!$2%$B$&'!,8$#!\2#F$&'!\'#$$'!2&(!B2L9&F!#$:$#$&3$!',!'4$!@Xbb!>/2&C!N4$!

)5#($&!42%!)$$&!5>,&!'4$!#$%>,&($&'%!',!%4,D!'4$!$G9%'$&3$!,:!'4$!%34$B$C!American'Unitarian'Assn.!8C!

Minot,!@X]!12%%C!]X^=!]^]C!N4$!O5(F$!D2 % !D2##2& ' $ ( !9& !3 , &3/5(9& F !' 4 2 ' !'4$!#$%> , & ( $ &'%!42( !( , &$!%,CJ!

Rahilly'v.'Addison,!Z]?!12%%C!AA?=!663'T12%%C!@^AAUC!

Statutory'Public'Ways!2#$!D2*%!/29(!,5'!2&(!233$>'$(!)*!',D&!,::9392/%!I:,#!'4$!5%$!,:!,&$!,#!B,#$!,:!'4$!

9&42)9'2 & '% e J!W C6 C!3C!X ;!% %C!; @ =!;Z =!2& ( !9%!H 5 2 %9[>5)/93C!N4$!B5&939>2/9'*!B2*!B2L$!#$>29#%=!>#,89($(!'4$!2>>/932&'!

#$9B)5#%$%!'4$!',D& C!N4$!>5)/93!F$&$#2//*!42%!'4$!#9F4'!',!5%$!2!%'2'5',#*!>5)/93!D2*C!

\,B$!,'4$#!/2D%!'42'!B2*!2>>/*!

N49%!9%!&,'!2&!$G425%'98$!/9%'=!)5'!>#,89($%!9&:,#B2'9,&!,&!%,B$!3,BB,&!/$F2/!9%%5$%!#$/2'$(!',!$2%$B$&'%C!!

• 12%%2345%$''%!W$&$#2/!62D!742> '$#!@X Z=!§ ]X!>#,89($%!2!legal'presumption !'4 2'!:$$!,D & $#%4 9>!,:!

2)5''$#%!',!D2*%!I#5&%!',!'4$!3$&'$#!/9&$!,:!'4$!D2*!eC!2&(!32##9$%!D9'4!9'!'4$!#9F4'!',!5%$!'4$!D2*!2/,&F!9'%!

$&'9#$!/$&F'4CJ!!Brennan'v.'DeCosta=!!;Y!12%% C+ >>C7'C!^ A X !T @ ^ XbU!T$B>42%9%!2(($(UC!!N49%!/$F2/!>#$%5B>'9,&!

32&!)$!,8$#3,B$!D4$&!2!/$ F2 /!D 2 *!9%!9B > , %$ (!$ &' 9#$/* !D 9'4 9&!'4 $ !), 5 &( 2 #9$% !,:!2 !>2 #3 $/C!-& !'4, %$ !32 %$% =!'4$ !

2)5''$#%!(,!&,'!IF$'J!$G'#2!/2&(!2(($(!',!'4$!3$&'$#!,:!'4$!D2*=!&,#!(,!'4$*!F$'!'4$!#9F4'!',!5%$!'4$!D2*=!

2)%$&'!2!F#2&'!,:!'4$!#9F4'!',!(,!%,C!!

• Merger!9%!D4$&!'4 $ !) $& $ :9'$ ( !2& ( !) 5 #( $& $ ( !> #, > $# '* !) $3 , B $ !5&9'$(!9&!'9'/$=!,#=!,D&$(!)*!'4$!%2B$!>$#%,&!

,#!$&'9'*C!!S,#!2&!$2%$ B$&'!',!$G9%'!9'!B5%'!F 98 $ !% , B$,&$ !' 4 $ !# 9F 4 ' !' , !5 % $ !> # , >$#'*!&,'!,D& $ ( !)*!'4$!

$2%$B$&'!4,/($#C!a&3$!'4$!'9'/$%!2#$!5&9'$(!9&!'4$!%2B$!>$#%,&!,#!$&'9'*=!'4$!$2%$B$&'!9%!$G'9&F59%4$(=!

)$325%$!'4$#$!9%!&,!/,&F$#!2!)5#($&$(!2&(!)$&$:9'$(!>#,>$#'*!`!,&$!>$#%,&!,D&%!9'!2//!%,!32&!5%$!9'!D9'4,5'!

&$$(!,:!2&!$2%$B$&'C!P4$&!,&$!,:!'4$!>2#3$/%!9%!F#2&'$(!',!%,B$,&$!$/%$=!'4$!$2%$B$&'!(,$%!&,'!#$2>>$2#=!

,#!%>#9&F!)23L!9&',!$G9%'$&3$C!+&!$&'9#$/*!&$D!$2%$B$&'!B5%'!)$!F#2&'$(C!N49%!2/%,!2>>/9$%!',!F#28$/!#9F4'%!

2&(!'4$!#9F4'!',!42#8$%'!'#$$%=!:,#!9&%'2&3$C!!

• Overburdening'of'an'easement!,335#%!D4$&!%,B$,&$!2''$B>'%!',!$G'$&(!'4$!$2%$B$&'!)$*,&(!'4$!/2&(!

'42'!42%!'4$!/$F2/!)$& $:9'!,:!'4$!$2 %$B $& '=!',!,'4$# !/2&(C!N4 9%!5%5 2//*!,33 5#% !D4 $&!2 &!,D & $#!,:!/2& (!23 H59#$ %!

2((9'9,&2/!/2&(!TI2:'$#[23H59#$(!>#,>$#'*J

]

U!2&(!2''$B>'%!',!5%$!'4$!$2%$B$&'!:,#!233$%%!',!'4$!2((9'9,&2/!

/2&(C!I-'!9%!'4$!/, & F[$%'2)/9%4$(!#5/$!9&!'4$!7,BB,&D$2/'4=!2%!$/%$D4$#$=!'42'!2:'$#[23H59#$(!

>#,>$#'*eCB2*!&,'!)$!2(($(!',!'4$!(,B9&2&'!$%'2'$eD9'4,5'!'4$!$G>#$%%!3,&%$&'!,:!'4$!,D&$#!,:!'4$!

%$#89$&'!$%'2'$e2)%$&'!%534!3,&%$& '=!'4$!5%$!,:!'4$!2&!$2%$B$&'!',!)$&$:9'!>#,>$#'*!/,32'$(!)$*,&(!'4$!

(,B9&2&'!$%'2'$!3,&%'9'5'$%!2&!,8$#)5#($&9&F!,:!'4$!$2%$B$&'CJ!T79'2'9,&%!,B9''$(U!McLaughlin'v.'

Selectmen'of'Amherst=!ZX!12%%C!+ > >C!7'C!@A;=!@A^!T@ ^^]UC!

• Abandonment!9%!2&!9&'$&'9, & !) *!' 4$ !$ 2% $B$&'!4, /($#=!)*!2!#$/$2%$=!,#!I23'%!)*!'4$!,D&$#!,:!'4$!(,B9&2&'!

$%'2'$!3,&3/5%98$/*!2&(!5&$H598,32//*!B2&9:$%'9&F!$9'4$#!2!>#$%$&'!9&'$&'!',!#$/9&H59%4!'4$!$2%$B$&'!,#!2!

>5#>,%$!9&3,&%9%'$&'!D9'4!9'%!:5#'4$#!$G9%'$&3$CJ!Dubinsky'v.'Cama=!;A@!12%%C!Yb!T@^; bUC!!+!3/$ 2# !9&'$ & '9,& !

&$8$#!',!B2L$!5%$!,:!'4$!$2%$B$&'!2F29&!B5%'!)$!%4,D&C!Sindler'v.'Bailey=!ZYX!12 % %C!]X^=!]^ ; !T @ ^ A ]UC!

_,&5%$!,#!:29/5#$!',!L$$>!'4$!$2%$B$&'!3/$2#!2/,&$!D9//!&,'!#$%5/'!9&!'4$!2)2&(,&B$&'!,:!2&!$2%$B$& 'C!-&'

Desotell'v.'Szczygiel=!ZZX!12%% C!@ ]Z=!@]^[@A?!T@^]XU=!2&!$2%$B$&'!3,8$#$(!D9'4!'#$$%!2&(!)#5%4!2&(!2!

F2#)2F$!(5B>!D2%!&,'!$&,5F4!',!>#,8$!'4$!$2%$B$&'!42(!)$$&!2)2&(,&$(C!\$$!2/%,!Brennan'v.'Decosta=!!;Y!

12%%C+>>C7'C!^AX!T@^XbUC!!!

• Frustration'of'the'purpose'of'the'easement!9%!D4$&!2&!$2%$B$&'!9%!$G'9&F59%4$(!D4$&!'4$!>5#>, %$!:,#!

D4934!'4$!$2%$B$&'!D2%!3#$2'$(!9%!&,!/,&F$#!2>>/932)/$C!IP4$&!2!#9F4'!9&!'4$!&2'5#$!,:!2&!$2%$B$&'!9%!

9&32>2) /$ !, :!) $9& F !$G $ #39% $ (!:, #!' 4$ !> 5 #> , % $!:, #!D4934!9'!9%!3#$ 2 '$ ( !'4 $!#9F 4 '!9%!3,& %9($#$( !$G'9&F 59%4 $(CJ!!

Makepeace'Bros.'v.'Town'of'Barnstable=!;^;!1 2 % % C!] @ X !T @ ^ Z]UT2&!$9F4'$$&'4!3$&'5#*!$2%$B$&'!:,#!D42/9&F!

D2%!$G'9&F59%4$(!)$325%$!D42/9&F!9%!&,!/,&F$#!(,&$CUC!-'!9%!B,#$!3,BB,&!',(2 *!D 4$& !$2%$B $& '!

3,&&$3'9,&%!',!2!3,BB,&!D$//=!,#!%$>'93!%*%'$B=!9%!&,!/,&F$#!&$3$%%2#*!)$325%$!'4$!>#,>$#'9$%!2#$!

3,&&$3'$(!',!B5&939>2/!D2'$#!2&(!%$D$#=!,#!D4$#$!'4$!$2%$B$&'!D2%!',!2//,D!32''/$!',!3#,%%!',!F$'!',!

F#2i9&F!:9$/(%!D4934!428$!)$$&!3,&8$#'$(!',!%5)(989%9,&%C!

• 12%%2345%$''%!W$&$#2/!62D%!742>'$#!@Xb=!§]!>#,89($%!2!right'to'install'utilitiesj!IN4$ !, D & $ # !, #!, D&$#%!,: !

#$2/!$%'2'$!2)5''9&F!,&!2!>#982'$!D2*!D4,!428$!)*!($$(!$G9%'9&F!#9F4'%!,:!9&F#$%%!2&(!$F#$%%!5>,&!%534!D2*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

]

!McLaughlin'v.'Board'of'Selectmen'of'Amherst=!Y;;!12%%C!Z]^=!ZAY!T@^^AU!T+:'$#!23H59#$(!>#,>$#'*!32&!

)$&$:9'!:#,B!2&!$2%$B$&'!%534!2%!'49%!,&$!,&/*!9:!'4$!$2%$B$&'!9%!2&!$2%$B$&'!9&!F#,%%=!2!>$#%,&2/!

9&'$#$%'!9&!,#!#9F4'!',!5%$!'4$!/2&(!,:!2&,'4$#=!,#!'4$!,D&$#!,:!'4$!2:'$#[23H59#$(!>#,>$#'*!#$3$98$%!'4$!

3,&%$&'!,:!,D&$#!,:!'4$!%$#89$&'!$%'2'$CJ!

,#!,'4$#!>#982'$!D2*%!%42//!428$!'4$!#9F4'!)*!9B>/932'9,&!',!>/23$=!9&%'2//!,#!3,&%'#53'!9&=!,&=!2/,&F=!5&($#!

2&(!5>,&!%29(!>#982'$!D2*!,#!,'4$#!>#982'$!D2*%!>9>$%=!3,&(59'%=!B2&4,/$%!2&(!,'4$#!2>>5#'$&2&3$%!

&$3$%%2#*!:,#!'4$!'#2&%B9%%9,&!,:!F2%=!$/$3'#939'*=!'$/$>4,&$=!D2'$#!2&(!%$D$#CCCJC!S,#!'49%!%'2'5'$!',!2>>/*=!

T@U!'4$!#9F4'%!,:!9&F#$%%!2&(!$F#$%%!B 5%'!) $!3#$2'$(!I)*!($$(J!T2&(!9&3/5($% !2!#$%$#82'9,& !,:!2&!$2%$B $ &'U Q!

T;U!'4$!D2*!B5 %'!)$!2!I>#982'$ !D2 *JQ!2&(!TZU!'4$ !>#,> $#'*!B 5% '!)$!I2)5 ''9&FJ!'4$ !>#982'$!D 2* =!D4934!

9&3/5($ %!2 !(# 98$ D2*!$2%$ B $ & 'C!!Barlow'v.'Chongris=!ZX!12%% C+>>C7' C!; ^ b =!;^^!T@^ ^]UC!!!!

• +&!$G'$&%98$!'#$2'B$&'!,:!zoning'!9%!)$*,& ( !'4 $!% 3, > $ !,:!'4 9% !> #$ %$ & '2 '9, & C!<, D$8$#=!'4$ !3, 5 # '%!4 2 8$ !:, 5 & (!

'42'!2&!2)5''$#M%!,D&$#%49>!9&'$#$%'!9&!2!> 2> $#!%'#$$ '!#$H5 9#$(!'42 '!'4$!,D & $#!)$ !O,9&$(!9&!2 !%5) (989%9,& !

2>>/932'9,&=!%,!#9F4'%!9&!2!>2>$#!%'#$$'!D9//!&$$(!',!)$!($'$#B9&$(!>#9,#!',!%5)B9''9&F!2!%5)9(989%9,&!>/2&C!

Silva'v.'Planning'Board'of'Somerset=!ZY!12% % C+ >>C7'C!Z Z ^ !T @ ^ ^ ZUC!!N49%!( ,$%!&,' !2 > >/*!',!+ _ V!>/2&% C!

a'4$#!#$%,5#3$%j!

4''>jkkDDDCB2%%CF,8k3,5#'%k32%$[/$F2/[#$%k/2D [/9)k/2D%[)*[%5)Ok2),5'k#,2 (%C4'B/!

"#$%$#89&F!<9%',#93!V9F4'%!,:!P2*!',!'4$!\$2=!;

!$(9'9,&=!@^^^!

4''>jkkDDD CB 2% %CF,8k $$2 k( ,3%k 3iB k 233 $%%k #9F4'%[',[%$2[42&(),,LC>(:!

.9%3,&'9&59&F!N,D&!2&(!7,5&'*!V,2(%!)*!6*&&!V5)$&%'$9&!@^^? !

4''>jkkDDDC(,5F/2%B2C,#Fk3((k>)k#$>,#'%kV,2(.9%3,&'9&52&3$C>(:!

.9%3,&'9&59&F!N,D&!2&(!7,5&'*!V,2(%!)*!6*&&!V5)$&%'$9&!@^^?=!5>(2'$(!;??Z!)*!+/$G2&(#2!.C!.2D%,&!

4''>jkkDDDC'4$'#5%'$$%C,#Fk2%%$'%k(,35B $& '%k4 9F4/2& ([3,BB5&9'9$%[9& 9'92 '98 $k . 9% 3, & '9& 5 9& F [ N,D &[7,5&'*[

V,2(%C>(:!

12%%2345%$''%!\'#$$'%!2&(!P2*%!:,#!\5#8$*,#%=!;?@@=!)*!SC!\*(&$*!\B9'4$#%!

4''>jkkDDDC&2''/$),#,C3,Bk%9'$%k&2''/$),#,B2k:9/$%k5AYk%'#$$'%[D2*%[B2*[;?@@C>(:!